Every spring someone calls the bottom of the market. This year it's Melbourne houses, with Sydney tipped to follow a few months behind. Before anyone acts on that, it's worth asking what actually sits underneath the call, and whether a buyer's agent's job is to predict the turn or to help you move well regardless of it.
The backdrop is genuinely unusual. Listings have been very low through spring and are expected to stay thin into December and January, which is normally the quiet season anyway. That part isn't controversial. What's more interesting is the geography. Total listings are rising faster in Perth, Brisbane and Adelaide than elsewhere, which points to more stock coming onto the market in those cities even as the east coast capitals stay tight. A rising listing count and a falling price aren't the same signal, and mixing them up is one of the more common mistakes buyers make when they hear market commentary secondhand.
What the Melbourne and Sydney split is actually showing
The case for Melbourne houses having already bottomed rests on investor activity in units in the lower price bands, where asking prices are said to be climbing. That's a specific, narrow slice of the market: apartments, not houses, and a segment investors watch closely because yield and price often move together there. It tells you something about sentiment in that bracket. It doesn't automatically tell you what's happening to a freestanding house three suburbs away.
Sydney's picture looks different. Some houses have changed hands well below where they sold a year earlier, and auctions are being pulled from the market for lack of bidder interest. That's a buyer's market signal in the parts of Sydney where it's showing up, but it isn't uniform across the city, and a single agent's patch of experience won't necessarily cover the suburb you're looking at.
Meanwhile in Brisbane, competition for well-presented stock hasn't gone anywhere. A property in Ascot reportedly drew five offers and sold to someone else entirely, and a Clayfield property sold above its asking price in the mid-$2 millions. Two cities, both described as supply-constrained in spring, producing completely different outcomes at the kitchen table. That's the part a timing call glosses over and a local buyer's agent is paid to know cold.
Why buyers lose money chasing a national headline
Here's the catch with "the market has turned." It's a city-level or even a segment-level statement being applied to a street-level decision. A buyer in inner Melbourne reading "houses have bottomed" might bid harder than the local evidence supports. A buyer in outer Sydney reading "prices are falling" might wait on a suburb where stock is still being fought over. The headline and the street rarely move in lockstep, and the gap between them is where buyers overpay or let a fair property go.
In plain English
- A national or city-wide call is not a suburb-level fact. Ask any agent you're considering for evidence specific to your target area, not just the general trend.
- "Listings are low" and "prices are falling" can both be true in the same city at once, in different segments.
- Investor activity in one price band, like lower-priced units, doesn't tell you what owner-occupier houses are doing.
- A bottom call for one city says nothing reliable about a different city, even one often bundled with it in commentary.
The economic noise sitting behind all of this
Some of what's driving the mood is genuinely outside the property market. Oil prices fell sharply in the space of a week following the recent US midterm elections, which eases one source of inflation pressure. The RBA had taken rates to a cycle high before this, and government bond yields have been volatile over the past couple of years, climbing well above 5% at one point before easing back. Markets are now pricing no further RBA rate hikes, which matters for borrowing capacity even if it says nothing about where a specific suburb's prices go next.
At the same time, there's genuine softness showing up in the labour market. Unemployment remains below 5% but is trending upward, and headline-grabbing redundancies, including a large cut at a well-known tech company along with distress signals from retail, are feeding into caution. Rental vacancy rates are reportedly at five-year highs, which is easing fears about runaway rental inflation even as tax settings around property investment are being reworked. None of this resolves the Melbourne-versus-Sydney argument. It just explains why the mood feels unsettled even in cities where stock is scarce.
What this means for how you choose help
If the market genuinely is uneven by city and by segment right now, the value of a buyer's agent isn't in calling the turn. It's in knowing the specific streets, the specific competition, and the specific sellers in your target area well enough to act without guessing. That's a very different skill to reading a trend line.
The questions that sort a shortlist
When you're comparing agents, the goal is to find out whether their experience matches the actual pocket you're buying in, not just the city.
Questions to ask
- How many properties have you bought in this specific suburb in the last six months?
- What's happening to auction clearance and withdrawal rates in this postcode specifically, not the city average?
- Are you seeing more competition or less for properties like the one I want, right now?
- What would make you tell me to wait, or to move quickly?
A good answer is specific: a number of recent purchases, a named pocket, a clear description of who else is bidding. A weak answer repeats the national headline back to you, which is a sign the agent hasn't checked the street-level evidence themselves.
Where to go from here
The split between what's happening in Melbourne, Sydney and Brisbane right now is a good example of why broad commentary is a starting point, not a decision tool. If you're weighing up whether this is your window, the more useful move is comparing buyer's agents who can show you evidence from your specific target area, not the market as a whole. You can compare buyer's agents in Melbourne, buyer's agents in Sydney or buyer's agents in Brisbane depending on where you're looking, and if stock is genuinely loosening up, it's also worth checking buyer's agents in Perth or buyer's agents in Adelaide where listings are rising faster. If you're new to this entirely, our guide to 10 things to know before buying your first home is a reasonable place to start before you talk to anyone.
| What you hear | What to actually check |
|---|---|
| "The market has bottomed" | Ask which property type and which specific suburbs, not the whole city |
| "Listings are low" | Check whether that's true in your target postcode, not just the state |
| "Prices are falling" | Confirm which segment, houses or units, and compare recent sale prices against asking |
| "Auctions are being withdrawn" | Ask the agent for the clearance rate in your specific pocket, not a city average |
None of this means timing doesn't matter. It means timing is local, and the only way to know what's true in your target area is to ask someone who's active there now, and to check what they tell you against a second or third opinion before you commit.
BuyerAgentFinder is a comparison and introduction service. Information is general and does not consider your personal situation. Confirm fees, services, and suitability directly with the buyer's agent.